I always felt like Pyramid Head, Butcher and Boogeyman were actually the same entity, but manifested in different forms based on the protagonist's past. So in other words, PH, Booeyman and Butcher are the same thing
I imagine them in the new silent hill game that they along with Robbie The Rabbit are all the same person I really hope they have some connections with that Andy kid from the novel game and Stanley from silent Hill 3.
If Pyramid Head were exclusive to Silent Hill 2, then why did he appear in Homecoming?
His role in Silent Hill was not just the manifestation of James' frustrations, he was the town's executioner that represented self-punishment. In James' case, Pyramid Head was the representation of his self-punishment over what happened with Mary, and likely what happened with Eddie. James' quote was "I was weak, that's why I needed you." which was said to the two Pyramid Heads he had to fight.
Later on, in Homecoming, he was seen walking around with his knife in Silent Hill where he was known as the Bogeyman. He would kill the main character's father by slicing him in half.
He appeared in Homecoming for Fanservice. He had no reason to be in Homecoming. They just threw him in because of the movie. A lot of things after 4 are simply referencing the movie for no reason other than to reference it.
Still you can't deny his badassery. I'm just wondering if they decide to bring back Pyramid Head, how Kojima will envision our favorite monster...or what horror he will spawn forth from his Metal Gear-heavy head.
well I just hope Pyramid Head and Robbie the Rabbit are Same person with Andy and Stanley as well.Also he could be responsible for shattered memories to make heather play his sadistic game and his avatar is john in silent hill shattered memories.I hope most characters from previous games appear with heather as the main character along with god/Samael with her/his angels Vatti,The Bogeyman/Losbel Vith, and the butcher as one of the main antagonists along with Pyramid head I just hope Silent Hill 9 will be better.